A sharp, funny and deeply human portrait, told through letters that carry more weight than any modern message ever could.
Menu


related posts ⇓
A sharp, funny and deeply human portrait, told through letters that carry more weight than any modern message ever could.
A novel with potential that ultimately falls short – hints at big ideas about power and criticism struggle to turn into something cohesive.
An immersive reflection on love and memory, Heart The Lover traces how early choices and missed opportunities continue to shape a life long after they are made.
Florence Knapp’s debut asks a simple but arresting question: what if the name you are given at birth alters the entire shape of your life?
Reviews of the books I read in November: ‘Crying in H Mart’ by Michelle Zauner & ‘Blue Sisters’ by Coco Mellors.

A woman washes up during a violent storm on a remote island that was once a research base but is now long abandoned except for its caretaker Dominic Salt and his three children. As Rowan is nursed back to health she begins to piece together what happened to the scientists who once lived there and why the island holds such personal meaning for her back on the mainland. What unfolds is a story of grief, environmental loss and human connection wrapped inside a tense mystery.
One of the novel’s greatest strengths is its shifting points of view. We move between Rowan, Dom and his three children, each voice offering a different lens on the island and its secrets. The chapters are short and propulsive, never breaking the flow of the storytelling. Even Orly, the youngest of the children, becomes compelling enough through his love of plants and the fragile ecosystem that surrounds them. Through these rotating perspectives McConaghy carefully feeds us fragments of the past, Dom’s precarious situation and the unanswered questions around the vanished researchers.
McConaghy’s writing is effortlessly readable yet rich in emotion. She has a gift for revealing just enough to keep you turning the pages, slowly unspooling the plot without ever feeling manipulative. The relationship between Rowan and Dom I found especially engaging. Even when you begin to sense where it might lead, it remains tender and absorbing, grounded in shared trauma and a need for connection rather than melodrama.
The island itself feels like a living presence in the book. McConaghy paints its wildness and hostility with such clarity that it becomes another character, contributing to decisions the characters make. The way she writes about the crumbling buildings being reclaimed by the harsh weather conditions and the wildlife that thrives there adds lovely facets to the setting. There is a deep respect for the natural world running through it, mirrored by the characters who live so carefully alongside it.
What makes Wild Dark Shore especially satisfying is that none of its main characters feel disposable or thinly drawn. I found myself most drawn to Rowan and Dom, watching their guarded trust grow into something more, but even the children leave a lasting impression. By the time the end arrived I felt as though you have truly lived on this island with them.
Overall, this is a haunting and immersive novel that creates its own complete world and then invites you to lose yourself inside it. I was genuinely sad to leave it behind and I will absolutely be seeking out more of Charlotte McConaghy’s work after this.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
related posts ⇓
A sharp, funny and deeply human portrait, told through letters that carry more weight than any modern message ever could.
An immersive reflection on love and memory, Heart The Lover traces how early choices and missed opportunities continue to shape a life long after they are made.
Florence Knapp’s debut asks a simple but arresting question: what if the name you are given at birth alters the entire shape of your life?
Reviews of the books I read in November: ‘Crying in H Mart’ by Michelle Zauner & ‘Blue Sisters’ by Coco Mellors.